%20(2).png)
Some horses stand out because they’re expressive, energetic, or quick to communicate their feelings. Others, however, seem to glide through life without resistance. They’re quiet, obedient, and easy to handle. They don’t spook, they don’t fuss, and they don’t demand much from their handlers. These horses are often praised as “good horses,” the kind anyone would love to own. But what if their silence is actually a sign of something deeper—something that needs our attention?
The Hidden Struggles of the Stoic Horse
Horses that are highly compliant and unreactive can sometimes be experiencing learned helplessness—a psychological state where they’ve shut down emotionally and physically in response to past experiences. Instead of expressing fear, frustration, or discomfort, they suppress their feelings. They might not resist handling, training, or changes in their environment, but that doesn’t mean they’re truly comfortable.
What Is Learned Helplessness?
Learned helplessness occurs when a horse repeatedly experiences situations where they feel powerless to change the outcome. Over time, they stop trying. This can happen when they’ve been trained with excessive pressure, punished for showing discomfort, or handled in ways that ignore their communication. When a horse learns that no matter what they do, they cannot influence their environment or avoid stress, they often disengage entirely.
In training, this might look like a horse that never resists, never hesitates, and never expresses preferences—things that might seem ideal but can actually indicate deep-seated emotional suppression. While an expressive, opinionated horse often gets attention and support, a horse in learned helplessness tends to be overlooked because they don’t “cause problems.”
Signs of Learned Helplessness in Horses
While each horse is different, some key signs that a horse may be in this state include:
Minimal reaction to separation – When companions leave, they don’t call out or become distressed. Instead, they stay eerily quiet.
Dull or slow responses – They take cues sluggishly, almost as if they’re disconnected from what’s happening.
Lack of response to novel stimuli – While some might view this as a sign of confidence, a horse that doesn’t react at all to something new or potentially scary could be internally shutting down rather than processing and responding appropriately.
Slower learning – These horses might take longer to pick up on new training, not because they’re less intelligent, but because they are mentally disengaged.
Stiff or lethargic movement – Their bodies may reflect their mental state, moving with hesitation or stiffness.
Absence of playfulness or curiosity – Even in a relaxed environment, they show little interest in their surroundings, herd mates, or novel objects.
At first glance, these horses may appear “calm,” but this kind of stillness isn’t the same as true relaxation. A relaxed horse may be quiet, but they also engage with their world—they move freely, investigate new things, and show a range of emotions. A horse in learned helplessness, on the other hand, often seems frozen in place—not just physically but emotionally.
The Difference Between a Calm Horse and a Shut-Down Horse
It’s important to distinguish between a horse that is naturally easygoing and one that has emotionally shut down. A horse who is genuinely calm will still show curiosity, personality, and engagement in their surroundings. They might be steady and reliable but will still communicate—whether through soft eye movement, ear flicks, or small shifts in body language.
A horse in learned helplessness, however, won’t show those small reactions. Their expressions may be blank, their movement hesitant, and their responses delayed. They may not actively resist anything, but they also don’t actively engage. Their compliance isn’t based on trust and understanding—it’s based on an internalized belief that their actions don’t matter.
How Horses Develop Learned Helplessness
This state can develop in many ways, but some common contributors include:
Harsh or inescapable pressure – Training methods that rely on excessive pressure without relief can teach a horse that there’s no point in responding because the discomfort never truly goes away.
Punishment for communication – If a horse is repeatedly corrected for showing fear (such as shying away, pinning ears, or resisting), they may stop trying to communicate altogether.
Forced exposure (“flooding”) – Repeatedly exposing a horse to overwhelming stimuli without a way to retreat or process the experience can cause them to mentally shut down.
Lack of choice in daily life – Horses that have no say in their interactions, turnout, or handling can begin to disengage from their environment entirely.
Because these horses don’t act out, their struggles are easy to miss. Instead of recognizing them as needing support, they are often praised for their “good” behavior. But if we take a closer look, we might see that they’re not okay—they just don’t know how to express it.
The Hidden Dangers of Learned Helplessness
While a shut-down horse might appear easy to handle, the long-term consequences of learned helplessness can be serious. Physically, these horses may be more prone to stress-related illnesses, ulcers, and muscle tension due to chronic low-level anxiety that goes unnoticed. Mentally, they can struggle to recover from fear or trauma, making rehabilitation and retraining more difficult.
Even more concerning, a horse in learned helplessness can suddenly “wake up” if they reach a breaking point, resulting in unexpected explosive behavior. When a horse that has been suppressing emotions finally reacts, the response can be severe—bolting, bucking, or panicked escape attempts. This is why it’s critical to recognize and address learned helplessness before a crisis occurs, ensuring that horses feel safe and heard, rather than silently enduring distress.
Helping the “Good” Horse Find Their Voice
If you recognize these signs in your horse, there are ways to help them reconnect with their body and emotions. The goal isn’t to make them more reactive but to encourage them to express themselves, engage with their environment, and rebuild a sense of agency.
1. Encourage Choice and Expression
Horses in a learned helpless state often don’t believe they have a choice. Introducing cooperative care—where the horse is actively involved in their own care—can be a game-changer. Simple things like letting them opt into grooming, adjusting their position for blanketing, or choosing whether they’re ready to interact can help build their confidence.
2. Incorporate Enrichment Activities
Providing opportunities for problem-solving, exploration, and engagement with their environment can help these horses rediscover their curiosity. Puzzle feeders, novel objects in their turnout space, and liberty play are all great options.
3. Supportive Bodywork
Horses in a shut-down state often hold tension in their bodies. Gentle bodywork—such as massage, stretching, or acupressure—can help them become more aware of themselves and their comfort. However, this should be consent-based and minimally invasive, allowing the horse to participate rather than simply tolerate the process.
4. Rebuild Their Confidence Through Training
Training should focus on engagement and communication rather than just obedience. Using positive reinforcement can help these horses regain their voice. Reinforce small moments of curiosity, enthusiasm, and voluntary interaction. Instead of expecting perfect compliance, celebrate moments where they begin to show personality and preference.
5. Prioritize Emotional and Physical Well-Being
Addressing learned helplessness is not just about training—it’s about looking at the whole picture. Assess their diet, turnout situation, social interactions, and any sources of chronic discomfort. A horse that feels safe, comfortable, and engaged in their life is more likely to show true enthusiasm and connection.
A Different Perspective on “Good” Horses
It’s easy to celebrate a horse that never says “no.” But we need to ask: Are they truly happy and engaged, or have they just learned that their voice doesn’t matter?
Supporting these horses goes beyond training—it’s about listening to them, helping them heal, and creating an environment where they feel safe enough to express themselves.
If you have a horse that fits this description, I encourage you to start looking for small ways to give them more choice and control. It might surprise you to see what happens when they start to believe their voice will be heard.
Comments